Robbery at Montilivi? VAR Controversy Clouds Girona’s Dramatic Winner Against Barcelona

​A storm of controversy has erupted in La Liga following Girona’s late 2-1 victory over FC Barcelona on Monday night (February 16, 2026). The match, which saw the Catalan giants surrender their lead at the top of the table to Real Madrid, was defined by a highly disputed officiating decision just moments before the winning goal.

The moment that sparked outrage in the Barcelona vs Girona match

​The turning point occurred in the 86th minute. As Girona pushed for a winner, young talent Claudio Echeverri appeared to clearly stamp on the foot of Barcelona defender Jules Koundé while advancing with the ball.

  • The Incident: Koundé fell to the ground in pain, but the referee, Soto Grado, allowed play to continue.
  • The Goal: Unaffected by the protest, Echeverri continued the attack, leading to Fran Beltrán rifling home a powerful strike from the edge of the box to make it 2-1.
  • VAR Silence: Despite a brief review, the VAR officials deemed the contact “part of the game,” much to the disbelief of Hansi Flick and his players.

A Night of Frustration for Hansi Flick

​The defeat was a bitter pill to swallow for the Blaugrana, who dominated large portions of the match:

  • Missed Opportunities: Lamine Yamal had a night to forget, missing a crucial penalty in the 45th minute that could have changed the match’s trajectory.
  • The Scoreline: Pau Cubarsí had initially put Barcelona ahead in the 59th minute, but his goal was cancelled out just three minutes later by Thomas Lemar.
  • Post-Match Rage: Following the final whistle, Hansi Flick and Raphinha were seen in a heated confrontation with the officiating crew, citing a “double standard” in how VAR is applied against Barcelona.
Barcelona
Barcelona

La Liga standings after Barcelona’s stumble against Girona

PosTeamPoints
1Real Madrid60
2FC Barcelona58
3Villarreal45
4Atletico Madrid45
5Real Betis41
6Espanyol35
7Celta Vigo34
8Real Sociedad31
9Athletic Bilbao31
10Osasuna30
11Getafe29
12Girona29
13Sevilla26
14Deportivo Alaves26
15Valencia26
16Elche25
17Rayo Vallecano25
18Real Mallorca24
19Levante18
20Real Oviedo16

Expert Analysis: Was it a Foul?

Spanish refereeing experts remain divided. While some believe Echeverri’s contact was accidental and unintentional, the majority of Catalan media outlets, including Mundo Deportivo, described the decision as a “technical robbery,” pointing out that such fouls are usually given in midfield.

Do you believe VAR made the right call in allowing the goal to stand, or has Barcelona been unfairly treated in the race for the title?

Related Posts

Should Lamine Yamal’s missed penalty against Girona have been retaken?

Lamine Yamal

Read more

How many penalties has Lamine Yamal missed in his career?

Lamine Yamal

Read more

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *